A Second Execution? A Second look at the Death Penalty

With the September 30, 2026 failed execution of Christa Pike, some legal scholars have started to debate whether it would be a violation of the 8th Amendment’s constitutional prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment to attempt to execute Pike a second time.[i] This botched execution has led Tennessee’s Prison Chief, Frank Strada, to resign while an independent review of the execution attempt occurs.[ii] In addition, all remaining executions in Tennessee this year have been paused.[iii] Another failed execution in Tennessee occurred earlier this year in May with Tony Carruthers, who has now been given a new execution date in May 2027.[iv] In Alabama, officials failed to execute two death row inmates due to failure to find a vein; they were later executed through an experimental procedure.[v] Other states have opted for the firing squad to avoid the unreliability of lethal injections, but those procedures have been called into question with some shots being mis-targeted intentionally.[vi] Currently, executions in the United States are unreliable, yet the U.S. experienced the highest number of executions across the states in 16 years last year, with 47 occurring.[vii]  States have limited options, raising questions about not only the reliability of execution methods but also the legal limit on a state’s ability to attempt an execution more than once.

International law does not provide helpful guidance on second-attempt executions, as it is oriented towards abolition of the death penalty entirely. More than 70% of countries have abolished the death penalty either in law or in practice.[viii] The U.S. remains an outlier among its allies and other democratic countries.[ix] It is one of two Group of Seven (G7) countries that still uses the death penalty, along with Japan.[x] China is the world’s leading executioner, with the majority of their death penalty data classified as a state secret.[xi] The death penalty is not prohibited by international law.[xii] However, many international organizations greatly oppose it.[xiii] The United Nations Human Rights Office views the use of the death penalty as inconsistent with every human’s right to life and to live free from torture, or cruel degrading punishment.[xiv] Most countries that have abolished the death penalty impose life imprisonment without the possibility of parole as the maximum sentence.[xv]  The international landscape favoring abolition is important context when considering the United States’ reliance on the practice, especially amid its unreliability.

After a failed execution, states’ options are limited: some schedule a new execution date after an independent review, like in the case of Tony Carruthers;[xvi] alternatively, clemency in the form of a reduction of the defendant’s sentence could be granted by the governor, but this is not a right and has never occurred following a failed execution.[xvii] The Supreme Court has held that proceeding with a second execution after a failed attempt due to a mechanical error does not violate the inmate’s constitutional rights.[xviii] Unless Pike is found to be cognitively or mentally impaired due to this execution attempt, she will likely be scheduled for another execution date.[xix]

The Supreme Court held in Gregg v. Georgia that the death penalty did not invariably violate the Constitution.[xx] Yet one major reason cited for opposing the death penalty is the view that it does exactly that, violate the 8th Amendment of the Constitution’s protection against cruel and unusual punishment.[xxi] Other reasons cited are the fact that it is applied unfairly against individuals based on their race — black Americans make up 40% of the death row population while making up only 12% of the U.S. population.[xxii] Also cited is the risk of executing innocent people: Since 1973, at least 203 people who were convicted and sentenced to death in the U.S. have been exonerated and numerous more have been declared innocent posthumously.[xxiii] Additionally, the death penalty does not provide the goal of deterrence or provide the necessary retribution victims and their families desire.[xxiv]

As stated in Gregg, the analysis of whether the 8th Amendment is violated requires looking at the “objective indicia that reflect the public attitude toward a given sanction.”[xxv] Chief Justice Warren explained that “[t]he Amendment must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society.”[xxvi] Under the Court’s own reasoning and the current public opinion of the death penalty, abolition should be seriously considered. The percentage of Americans who oppose the death penalty for a person convicted of murder is at a record high (44%).[xxvii] Half of those polled believe the death penalty is unfairly applied and 60% believe life imprisonment is a better penalty for murder.[xxviii] America’s sentiment towards the death penalty is continuously favoring its abolishment. This must be reflected by the Court’s interpretation of the 8th Amendment.

Because the United States is a clear outlier among democratic countries in its use of the death penalty, and because changing public sentiment requires a reconsideration under Gregg, it should follow its allies in abolishing the death penalty and designating life imprisonment without the possibility of parole as the maximum sentence.


Isabella de la Vega is a staff member of Fordham International Law Journal Volume L.

[i] See Ed Pilkington, Calls Grow for US Death Penalty Halt After “Torturous” Botched Execution of Christa Pike, The Guardian (Oct. 2, 2026), https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/oct/02/us-death-penalty-christa-pike-tennessee.

[ii] See Emily Cochrane, Facing Fury Over Failed Execution, Tennessee Prison Chief Steps Down, N.Y Times, (Oct. 3, 2026), https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/03/us/tennessee-prison-commissioner-resigns-christa-pike.html.

[iii] See id.

[iv] See Pilkington, supra note 1.

[v] See id.

[vi] See id.

[vii] See id.

[viii] See International, Death Penalty Information Center, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/international.

[ix] See id.

[x] See Nina Motazedi, Japan Hangs Man in First Execution of 2026, Joining U.S. as Only G7 Nations to Execute, Death Penalty Information Center (Sep. 4, 2026), https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/japan-hangs-man-in-first-execution-of-2026-joining-u-s-as-only-g7-nations-to-execute.

[xi] See Death Penalty, Amnesty International, https://www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/death-penalty/.

[xii] See Death Penalty Information Center, supra note 10.

[xiii] See Amnesty International, supra note 13; World Coalition Against the Death Penalty, https://worldcoalition.org/; International Commission Against Death Penalty, https://icomdp.org/.

[xiv] See Death Penalty, United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, https://www.ohchr.org/en/topic/death-penalty.

[xv]  See Maximum Penalties, Sentencing Advisory Council, https://www.sentencingcouncil.vic.gov.au/about-sentencing/maximum-penalties (Australia’s maximum penalty is life imprisonment); see Types of prison sentence, GOV.UK, https://www.gov.uk/types-of-prison-sentence/life-sentences (The United Kingdom has “whole life orders” meaning they will never be released from prison unless under exceptional compassionate circumstances).

[xvi] See Spain and Belgium Abolish the Death Penalty, Prison Legal News, (May 15, 1996) https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/1996/may/15/spain-and-belgium-abolish-the-death-penalty/ (In Spain, the death penalty was abolished in 1995, with the last executions taking place decades before in 1975. In addition, in Belgium, the last execution took place in 1950); Specific Themes, Kingdom of Belgium, https://diplomatie.belgium.be/en/policy/policy-areas/human-rights/specific-themes/abolition-death-penalty (Belgium abolished the death penalty in 1996).

[xvii] See Clemency, Death Penalty Information Center, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/clemency.

[xviii] See Louisiana ex rel. Francis v. Resweber, 329 U.S. 459, 466 (1947).

[xix] See Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304, 321 (considering the deterrent and retributive purpose of the death penalty, the Court held the death penalty was an excessive punishment restricted by the Constitution if placed on that of “a mentally retarded offender”).

[xx] See Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153, 187 (1976).  

[xxi] See The Case Against the Death Penalty, ACLU (Dec. 11, 2012), https://www.aclu.org/documents/case-against-death-penalty.

[xxii] See Taylor Bonner, What to Know: Race and the Death Penalty, Death Penalty Information Center (Sep. 18, 2026), https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/what-to-know-race-and-the-death-penalty.

[xxiii] See Innocence, Death Penalty Information Center, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/innocence; Posthumous Declarations of Innocence, Death Penalty Information Center, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/innocence/posthumous-declarations-of-innocence.

[xxiv] See Arguments for and Against the Death Penalty, Death Penalty Information Center, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/resources/high-school/about-the-death-penalty/arguments-for-and-against-the-death-penalty; ACLU, supra note xxiii.

[xxv] 428 U.S. at 173.

[xxvi] Id. (citing Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86, 101 (1958)).

[xxvii] Death Penalty Polls, Gallup, https://news.gallup.com/poll/1606/death-penalty.aspx.

[xxviii] Id.


This is a student blog post and in no way represents the views of the Fordham International Law Journal.