From Opinion to Outcome?: The ICJ’s Climate Opinion and the Rockhopper v. Italy Rehearing

On July 23, 2025, the International Court of Justice (“ICJ”) issued an advisory opinion asserting that States have a legal obligation to protect the climate.[i] Investor-state dispute settlements (“ISDS”) have often been used by investors to combat environmental measures taken by states.[ii] Such was the case in Rockhopper v. Italy.[iii]  Prior to the ICJ advisory opinion, Rockhopper was awarded a substantial amount for Italy’s concession denial, deemed to be direct expropriation.[iv] The award from Rockhopper v. Italy was annulled for procedural reasons and a new tribunal has been constituted.[v] However, now that the ICJ has released the opinion, it raises the question of how international investment agreements, like the one in Rockhopper will be interpreted.[vi] Rockhopper v. Italy may be a key indicator of how tribunals will interpret climate obligations in the wake of the ICJ Opinion.[vii] 

In August of 2014, Rockhopper Exploration acquired Medoil, which held an exception from Italy’s ban on offshore extraction of oil within a 12-mile zone of the coast.[viii] After a series of revocations and exceptions, in 2015, Italy reinstated the ban.[ix] Subsequently, in 2016, the Italian Ministry for Economic Development informed Rockhopper that its application for an offshore production concession was rejected.[x] In response, Rockhopper filed an ICSID arbitration under the Energy Charter Treaty.[xi] Although Italy had argued that the ban was founded in the precautionary principle and was a legitimate exercise of regulatory authority, the tribunal found Italy to have engaged in direct expropriation.[xii] In cases of expropriation, compensation is required unless it is a bona fide exercise of police powers.[xiii] Italy claimed police powers, but this claim was rejected — the tribunal reasoned that Italy had already approved an environmental impact assessment and that, therefore, its actions were the result of succumbing to political pressure rather than to adhering to genuine environmental concerns.[xiv] The result was an award of approximately €190 million plus interest.[xv] But in 2025, the award was annulled in its entirety for procedural reasons. A new tribunal was constituted on March 9, 2026, which will take up the case again.[xvi] 

 The ICJ’s July 2025 advisory opinion, which was published in the interim, provides that states have an obligation to take ambitious mitigation measures to hit global climate change targets.[xvii] The opinion finds that states, as part of their due diligence obligations, are responsible for regulating private actors within their state.[xviii] The standard the ICJ sets is a stringent one.[xix] The ICJ was also very clear that climate treaties are not the only sources that bind states to their climate goals, as customary international law also plays a role.[xx] In Judge Cleveland’s Declaration, it is stated, “the interpretation of investment instruments must be informed by States’ obligations in respect of climate change under international law.”[xxi] Although the ICJ opinion is non-binding on states, its  persuasiveness cannot be underestimated,[xxii] especially since  the UN welcomed the opinion on May 20, 2026.[xxiii] When introducing the UN resolution to welcome the ICJ opinion, Representative Odo Tevi stated that the ICJ opinion “confirms that the protection of the climate system is a matter of legal obligation, not political discretion.”[xxiv] The resolution passed with 141 votes in favor.[xxv] 

 The resubmitted case of Rockhopper v. Italy presents a unique situation that could provide insight into how tribunals will evaluate investor claims in light of the ICJ opinion.[xxvi] The resubmitted case remains substantially the same except for the legal backdrop against which it now rests.[xxvii] In the first Rockhopper v. Italy, Italy’s police powers defense was rejected, and compensation awarded to Rockhopper.[xxviii] In the upcoming determination, Italy’s police powers defense holds much more weight given the ICJ opinion and its stringent demand for due diligence.[xxix] Considering the ICJ opinion, the regulations Italy had enacted and its subsequent rejection of Rockhopper’s application could be seen as part of its obligations.[xxx] Therefore, the ICJ opinion provides an avenue for the new Rockhopper v. Italy to provide a different result.[xxxi] Whether the tribunal chooses to use that avenue is yet to be determined.[xxxii] Questions regarding whether tribunals will cite and apply the opinion, whether tribunals are able to decide cases in isolation from climate concerns, and how climate obligations coincide with treaty interpretations could be determined by how the tribunal decides Rockhopper v. Italy.[xxxiii]


Nina Cassaway is a staff member of Fordham International Law Journal Volume L.

[i]See Obligations of States in Respect of Climate Changer, Advisory Opinion, 2025 I.C.J. No. 187, ¶ 457(3)(A)-(B) (July 2023) [hereinafter Advisory Opinion].

[ii] See Lukas Schaugg, Natalie Jones & Jeffrey Qi, Historic International Court of Justice Opinion Confirms States’ Climate Obligations, Int’l Inst. for Sustainable Dev. (July 28, 2025), https://www.iisd.org/articles/deep-dive/icj-advisory-opinion-climate-change; Nicolò Andreotti, Systemic Integration and Environmental Obligations in Investment Arbitration: Reassessing Rockhopper v. Italy, 17 J. Int’l Disp. Settlement [first page of article], 1 (2026).

[iii] See Rockhopper Italia S.p.A. v. Italian Republic, ICSID Case no. ARB/17/14, Award, ¶¶ 87, 99–100 (Aug. 23, 2022) [hereinafter Award]; Andreotti, supra note 2, at 2, 8.

[iv] See Award, supra note 3, ¶¶150, 167, 194.

[v] See Rockhopper Italia S.p.A. v. Italian Republic, ICSID Case no. ARB/17/14, Decision on Annulment, ¶ 435 (June 2, 2025) [hereinafter Decision on Annulment]; New Tribunal Constituted for Rockhopper v. Italy Resubmission, with Meg Kinnear as Chair, Inv. Treaty News (Apr. 21, 2026), https://www.iisd.org/itn/2026/04/21/new-tribunal-constituted-for-rockhopper-v-italy-resubmission-with-meg-kinnear-as-chair/ [hereinafter New Tribunal Constituted].

[vi] See Andreotti, supra note 2, at 1–2.

[vii] See New Tribunal Constituted, supra note 6.

[viii] See Alessandra Arcuri, Kyla Tienhaara & Lorenzo Pellegrini, Investment Law v. Supply-Side Climate Policies: Insights from Rockhopper v. Italy and Lone Pine v. Canada, 24 Int’l Env’t Agreements 193, 199–200 (2024); Award, supra note 3, ¶ 95.

[ix] See Award, supra note 3, ¶¶ 96–97; Andreotti, supra note 3, at 8.

[x] See Award, supra note 3, ¶ 96; Arcuri et al., supra note 8, at 200.

[xi] See Award, supra note 3, ¶ 87; Energy Charter Treaty art. 26, Dec. 17, 1994, 2080 U.N.T.S. 95.

[xii] See Award, supra note 3, ¶¶ 194, 197; Arcuri et al., supra note 8, at 200–01.

[xiii] See Magyar Farming Co. v. Hungary, ICSID Case No. ARB/17/27, Award, ¶ 366 (Nov. 13, 2019); Andreotti, supra note 3, at 16–17.

[xiv] See Award, supra note 3, ¶¶ 197–198, Andreotti, supra note 3, at 8–9, 16.

[xv] See Award, supra note 3, ¶ 201.

[xvi] See Decision on Annulment, supra note 6, ¶¶ 411-16, 435.

[xvii] See New Tribunal Constituted, supra note 6.

[xviii] See Advisory Opinion, supra note 1, ¶ 457(3)(A).

[xix] See id. ¶¶ 280, 282.

[xx] See id. ¶¶ 283–84; Caroline E. Foster, The 2025 International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion on Obligations of States in Respect of Climate Change, 74 Int’l & Compar. L.Q. 775, at 782, 784 (2025).

[xxi] See Advisory Opinion, supra note 1 ¶ 162–171, 457(3)(B); Foster, supra note 20, at 777.

[xxii] Advisory Opinion, supra note 1, ¶ 22 (declaration of Cleveland, J.).

[xxiii] See Andreotti, supra note 3, at 2; General Assembly Backs Historic World Court Climate Crisis Ruling, UN News (May 20, 2026), https://news.un.org/en/story/2026/05/1167561.

[xxiv] See G.A. Res. 80/263 (May 20, 2026); UN News, supra note 23.

[xxv] Naureen Hossain, UN General Assembly Votes for Resolution on ICJ Advisory Ruling on Climate Obligations, Inter Press Serv. (May 21, 2026), https://www.globalissues.org/news/2026/05/21/43101 (quoting Odo Tevi, Permanent Representative of Vanuatu to the United Nations).

[xxvi] See UN News, supra note 23.

[xxvii] See New Tribunal Constituted, supra note 6; Andreotti, supra note 3, at 7.

[xxviii] See Andreotti, supra note 3, at 10.

[xxix] See Award, supra note 3, ¶ 197.

[xxx] See Andreotti, supra note 3, at 3, 17–18; Advisory Opinion, supra note 1, ¶ 138; G.A. Res. 80/263, supra note 24.

[xxxi] See Advisory Opinion, supra note 1, ¶¶138, 295, 298; Andreotti, supra note 3, at 5, 17.

[xxxii] See Andreotti, supra note 3, at 17,19.

[xxxiii] See id. at 9–10, 14–15.

This is a student blog post and in no way represents the views of the Fordham International Law Journal.